As pricing eases, agencies may need to rethink renewal conversations, remarketing and growth targets.

For years, independent agents have helped clients deal with sharp premium increases and find coverage when carrier options were limited. For most, competition is returning and rate increases are slowing, giving clients more options at renewal. The shift varies by line, region and risk, but agencies face a renewed challenge – keeping clients who have more choices.

Renewal increases have also contributed to revenue growth for many agencies. If those increases slow, the same retained book can produce less growth, putting greater weight on retention, account growth and new business.

Reopen the Renewal Conversation
When premiums rise year after year, clients notice the cost. When increases moderate or alternatives become more available, they may look more closely at what they receive for that cost. A renewal notice alone may not show the agency’s value or give clients a reason to call before they start comparing options.

Reach out before the renewal is in front of the client. Ask what has changed in the household or business, check whether coverage still fits and explain any important renewal changes. A conversation about a new vehicle, a home renovation, a payroll change or a new contract can surface needs that a price comparison alone will miss. Consistent contact helps clients understand that the agency is paying attention between renewals, too.

Make Remarketing Purposeful
More options can make remarketing worthwhile, but shopping every account can create unnecessary disruption without improving the outcome. Set clear reasons to take an account to market. A substantial premium change, a shift in the client’s risk, a carrier appetite change or a client’s request may justify a closer look.

When you do remarket, compare the whole placement. Check limits, deductibles, exclusions, service expectations and the client’s circumstances, not only the premium. If the alternative is not a better fit, explain why keeping the current coverage may be the right choice. Before remarketing, discuss what the client hopes to improve and whether a change in carrier is likely to meet that goal.

Reset the Growth Plan
A 2027 plan should separate premium-driven revenue from growth the agency can create through retained clients, new accounts and broader coverage where it fits. If renewal increases slow, the agency may need more new business to reach its goals. Make sure producer expectations reflect that possibility and emphasize prospecting, follow-up and the types of accounts the agency is prepared to serve well.

Review client retention, policies in force (PIF), new business and premium together. These measures can help show whether changes in premium reflect more or fewer policies, or changes on existing accounts. Carrier conversations matter as well. Ask about changing appetite and discuss the types of clients and risks your agency plans to pursue. Early, candid communication can help producers focus their efforts and give underwriters a clearer picture of the risks the agency is bringing forward.

In a hard market, clients may have stayed because alternatives were scarce. As choices change, retention depends more on whether clients see the agency’s advice, attention and follow-through. The work begins before the renewal arrives.

TOP